Both lift conversions but serve different jobs. How to decide which (or both) belongs on your trades site.
After running both AI chatbots and live chat across dozens of trades sites, here's the honest breakdown of when each wins.
AI chatbots win on availability. They answer at 2am, qualify prospects while you sleep, and book consultations straight to your calendar. Modern AI bots (built on GPT-class models) handle 80%+ of common questions accurately.
AI chatbots win on cost. A capable chatbot setup runs $50–200/month. A part-time live chat agent runs $1,500+/month for the same coverage.
Live chat wins on complex sales. For high-ticket work ($10K+), a real conversation builds trust a bot can't. A trained human will out-close a bot every time.
Live chat wins on emergencies. When someone's basement is flooding, they don't want a bot. They want a human who can dispatch help right now.
Hybrid wins for most trades. Use an AI chatbot to qualify and triage, then hand hot leads to a real person during business hours and capture contact info after hours.
Whichever you pick, measure two numbers every month: chats started and qualified leads produced. If qualified leads aren't going up, fix the script before blaming the tool.
Want results like these for your business?
Let's talk about a marketing strategy that actually drives revenue.
Get a Free Quote